We compared the most popular clothing subscription boxes and personal styling services on price, styling fees, return policies, and how personal the experience really is. Here is how they stack up.
Take the style quizA good clothing subscription box should save you time, fit your real life, and not nickel-and-dime you with styling fees or forced returns. We weighted those factors most heavily, along with whether the service works for both men and women.
UrbaneBox is a personal styling service and clothing subscription box for both men and women. A real human stylist reads your style quiz and hand-picks every piece, with no styling fee, free shipping, and everything yours to keep. Plans start at $99.99 per month, and you can skip or cancel anytime.
Take the style quiz →Stitch Fix is one of the most recognized styling services. It pairs algorithm-driven recommendations with a stylist, and works on a try-and-return model where you keep what you like and send the rest back. A styling fee applies per shipment, credited toward items you keep.
UrbaneBox vs Stitch Fix →ThreadBeast is a men's clothing subscription known for streetwear and urban style. It delivers a surprise-style box of apparel and accessories on a tiered membership. It is a good fit if that specific aesthetic is what you want, but it is men-focused and less personalized than a quiz-driven service.
UrbaneBox vs ThreadBeast →Wantable offers styled edits for men and women across apparel, activewear, and sleepwear. You take a quiz, receive a curated edit, then keep what you want and return the rest. A styling fee applies and is credited toward what you keep, similar to other try-and-return services.
UrbaneBox vs Wantable →Stately is a styling subscription offering curated outfits for men and women. A stylist builds a box around your profile and you keep the pieces you want. It leans toward complete, coordinated outfits, which appeals to people who want a head-to-toe look rather than individual items.
UrbaneBox vs Stately →Menlo Club (formerly Five Four Club) is a men's apparel membership that sends a set of pieces each month for a flat membership price. It is value-focused and house-brand driven, so it works for men who want a simple, low-cost monthly refresh rather than a highly personalized styling experience.
UrbaneBox vs Menlo Club →Many services charge a styling fee per shipment. It is usually credited toward items you keep, but if you keep little, it adds up. UrbaneBox charges no styling fee, so the full price goes toward clothing.
Try-and-return boxes like Stitch Fix and Wantable let you send back what you don't want, but you have to manage returns within a window. Keep-everything boxes like UrbaneBox skip that hassle.
Some boxes are surprise-based, while others are quiz-driven and curated by a real stylist. If getting pieces you will actually wear matters most, a human-curated service tends to deliver better.
The best clothing subscription box depends on your needs, but for most people who want personal styling for men or women with no styling fee and no required returns, UrbaneBox is our top pick. Stitch Fix and Wantable are strong try-and-return options.
For women, UrbaneBox offers a personalized clothing subscription box with a real stylist, no styling fee, and free shipping. Stitch Fix and Wantable also serve women with a try-and-return model.
For men, UrbaneBox provides a personalized box with no styling fee and a real stylist. ThreadBeast suits men who want streetwear, and Menlo Club is a budget-friendly membership option.
Clothing subscription boxes are worth it if you value time saved and personal styling. The best value comes from boxes with no styling fee where you keep everything, since you are paying only for clothes.
Personalized for men and women. No styling fee. Keep everything. Take the 3-minute quiz and your first box is upgraded free.
Take the style quizWe use cookies to improve your experience. Learn more