Both deliver clothing to your door each month for a flat price. The difference is personalization, brand selection, and whether the box is built for both men and women. Here is an honest side-by-side comparison.
Take the style quizHere is how the two clothing subscriptions compare on the factors that matter most when deciding which one to join.
| Feature | UrbaneBox | Menlo Club |
|---|---|---|
| Personalization | Stylist reads a detailed quiz | Limited, house-brand sets |
| Built for | Men and women | Primarily men |
| Who picks your clothes | A real human stylist | Curated house picks |
| Brand range | Premium and varied brands | Mostly in-house brands |
| Keep everything | Yes, yours to keep | Yes, yours to keep |
| Men and women | Both | Primarily men |
| Free shipping | Yes, both ways | Included with membership |
| Skip or cancel anytime | Yes | Yes |
| Starting price | $99.99/mo, personally styled | Lower flat membership price |
Menlo Club sends curated house-brand sets with limited personalization. UrbaneBox is driven by a detailed style quiz that a real stylist reads before choosing each piece, so your box reflects your stated preferences.
Menlo Club is built largely around its own in-house brands. UrbaneBox curates from a wider, more premium range of brands, which gives more variety in what shows up in your box.
Menlo Club is primarily a men's membership. UrbaneBox offers both a men's and a women's clothing subscription, so it works for anyone and makes a flexible gift.
Yes. UrbaneBox is a strong Menlo Club alternative for people who want more personalization, a wider range of premium brands, and a box for both men and women rather than mostly men's house-brand basics.
Menlo Club is a flat-price men's membership built around house brands with limited personalization. UrbaneBox is a personally styled box for men and women, with a real stylist, a wider brand range, and no styling fee.
Menlo Club typically has a lower flat membership price, but it offers less personalization and mostly house brands. UrbaneBox starts at $99.99 per month for a personally styled box with premium brands and no styling fee.
Yes. A real human stylist reads your style quiz and hand-picks every piece in your box, rather than relying on an algorithm.
Personalized for men and women. No styling fee. Keep everything. Take the 3-minute quiz and your first box is upgraded free.
Take the style quizSee also: UrbaneBox vs Stitch Fix · Best clothing subscription boxes
We use cookies to improve your experience. Learn more